State of Guatemala Wins Arbitration Against Iberdrola

The International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) of the World Bank, has ruled against the claim of the Spanish company Iberdrola against the State of Guatemala.

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

The lawsuit filed by Iberdrola, a major shareholder and operator of the Empresa Electrica de Guatemala (EEGSA), in late 2009, was due to a disagreement on the rate of Value Added Distribution (VAD), in force since August 2008.

The ICSID also condemned the Spanish company to pay $5.3 million for the costs of the legal process.

"The decision of the tribunal, based in Washington and released on Monday August 20 2012, was to 'deny the claim of the Claimant (Iberdrola) that the Republic of Guatemala in this case committed acts of denial of justice' .



More on this topic

Million-dollar Sue Against Mine Suspension

December 2018

Representatives of the El Tambor mine, located in San José del Golfo and San Pedro Ayampuc, filed a $300 million lawsuit against the State of Guatemala.

The arbitration lawsuit was filed by the Americans Daniel W. Kappes, Kappes, Cassidy & Associates, which was registered by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) last December 11th.

$90 million Law Suit Against Costa Rican State

September 2012

The concessionaire of the route San Jose – Caldera, , Autopistas del Sol, has filed a lawsuit against the state demanding an update of the cost of road construction.

The company is seeking to "rebalance the contract based solely on an update of the amount of the original bid", said Luis Diego Flores, constitutional attorney.

State of Guatemala vs Teco Energy Litigation

August 2012

A recent ruling by an international tribunal in a dispute between Guatemala and Iberdrola, sets a precedent against the claims of Teco Energy.

The U.S. Corporation Teco Energy, a former shareholder of Empresa Eléctrica de Guatemala (EEGSA), sued Guatemala before the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), in 2010, claiming economic losses caused by a reduction in the Value Added Distribution implemented by the National Energy Commission in 2008.

TECO challenges Guatemalan tariff actions

January 2009

TECO Energy Inc. said earnings at its subsidiary in Guatemala have been cut following actions of a Guatemalan regulatory agency.

As publish in bizjournals.com: "The subsidiary, TECO Guatemala Holdings LLC, has filed notice that it will file an arbitration claim against the Republic of Guatemala under the Dominican-Republic-Central America-United States Free Trade Agreement, or DR-CAFTA, TECO said in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. In July, Guatemala’s National Electric Energy Commission unilaterally reset the distribution tariff for Empresa Eléctrica de Guatemala at levels well below the then existing tariff, the filing said. TECO Guatemala Holdings has a 24 percent interest in Empresa through a joint venture, and the action caused a “significant reduction” in earnings for the joint venture segment, the filing said."