Rice in Costa Rica: The Poor Subsidizing The Rich

The subsidy of $190 million paid by consumers "will not primarily go to producers but to large industrial companies which process domestic crops and who are, at the same time, importers."

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

In his blog on Elfinancierocr.com, Juan Carlos Hidalgo discusses the singular phenomenon that occurs in Costa Rica, where the rice policy initially intended to protect small rice producers, has become an unjust wealth transfer mechanism between sectors of society.

"... According to a study by the Institute for Research in Economics at the University of Costa Rica (ICSI) *, the poor consume more rice and, therefore, devote a larger percentage of their monthly resources to buying the grain. While the poorest section of the population spends 5% of their income buying rice, the richest section designate only 0.3% for that purpose. Moreover, 48% of domestic consumption of rice is done by poor households or those at risk of falling into poverty (Sections I and II)."

"... Any rice policy that makes grain prices artificially more expensive disproportionately affects the most vulnerable section of the population. And that is precisely what we have in Costa Rica ... "

"... The economist Ricardo Monge estimates at approximately $190.4 million the annual cost, which represents for Costa Rican consumers the difference between eating rice produced in Costa Rica and imported rice. Again, since low-income families are consuming more of this product, it is they who contribute the most to the subsidy given by consumers to producers and agribusinesses. "

"... 6 companies are left with 90.1% of the subsidy that corresponds to industrialists, or $117.8 million. One company alone, Compañía Arrocera Industrial S.A., pockets $35.5 million a year."

"... of the $190.4 million extra paid by Costa Rican rice consumers , 98.84% ends up in the pockets of medium and large industrial producers, while only 1.16% is distributed among the 379 small local farmers. "

¿Busca soluciones de inteligencia comercial para su empresa?

More on this topic

The Rice Issue Reveals the New Government of Costa Rica

May 2014

The next Minister of Agriculture talks about subsidies to "the others" and "unfair competition", but not about the dramatic differences in productivity between Costa Rican rice producers and those "others".  

The appointed Minister of Agriculture, Luis Felipe Arauz, has announced that he will review - in order to extend- the deadline set by the outgoing government to liberalize the price of rice.

Rice Subsidies in Panama

September 2012

The government is considering indirect forms of subsidy such as rewards for farmers with increased production or improved productivity, in order to avoid the impact on the population of an increase in grain prices.

The rising price of rice in global markets is directly affecting Panama, which annually consumes 8.5 million quintals, of which it must import about 3 million, in order to supplement local production which reaches approximately 5.5 million quintals.

Rice in Costa Rica: A Sweet Deal

July 2012

In the past four years, the number of farmers engaged in rice production increased from 743 to 1,200, drawn by a fixed price system which in 2011 was covered by a subsidy amounting to $104 million.

The recent judgment by the Administrative Court annulling a presidential decree and ordering an increase in the price of a 73 kilo bag of rice to almost $49, confirms the wisdom of farmers who switched to growing the grain, confident that the subsidy levels would continue at astonishing levels, despite protests from other countries, the opinion of the World Trade Organization (WTO), and consumers of a product based on the local food basket, who pay one of the highest prices in the world for rice.

Costa Rica: $104 million in Rice Subsidies in 2011

May 2012

In the last 5 years the pricing system in force has transferred more than $390 million from the pockets of consumers to rice producers.

A statement of the Ministry of Commerce reads:

Rice sector subsidies in excess of $100 million for the second year

San Jose, May 8th, 2012.