Guatemala (Badly) Viewed from Germany

Although Central American countries have big problems that impair their image abroad, it is sometimes the small episodes that stand out as unacceptable when viewed from abroad by modern society.

Wednesday, May 20, 2015


Many politicians would have the people they lead believe that the main function of the state is welfarism, when the road to prosperity and social justice begins with the proper functioning of the judiciary and will of the state to enforce the law. If the State complies properly with these primary functions, development is protected from the fickleness of any bad leaders, and formation of a culture of justice and respect for the rules, which is essential to human progress, is assured.

That is why, as noted in an article on, more impact is caused and more news spread in Europe about the dispute between the German School and the family of an expelled student, than the resignation of the Vice President Baldetti and her links with the network of customs corruption.

The article reports that the prestigious media outlet Spiegel Online publishes "... a large article that creates the impression that the Guatemalan legal system continues to operate the usual as when in Europe the country was considered a banana republic. It portrays a State in which the rich and powerful manage the legal system at will. "

After the expulsion from the German School of three students over a sexual incident ... "The parents of two boys accepted the expulsion. But one family opposed it and sought support from the highest political and legal levels in the country. "

While the director of the College insisted "... in its right of admission of students to the private institution that he heads, ... the family lawyers concentrated on the right to education."

After mediation methods failed, the Guatemalan justice system ruled in favor of the family ruling that "... The German School in Guatemala exceeded the limits on correction and that the student's human right to education was ignored and violated."

"... The Director Guido Goser returned to his home in Germany. In a correspondence via Internet he regreted that the publication by Spiegel Online created the impression that the legal system in Guatemala defends the interests of a small group of powerful people. 'I know that many people are dedicated to changing this. But I have to admit that I personally saw no other way to get out of this situation. '"

"... Spiegel Online cites German jurists who could not hide their astonishment. They say it would be "unthinkable" that something similar could happen in Germany, considering the disproportionality of the original problem and the current consequences. "

¿Busca soluciones de inteligencia comercial para su empresa?

More on this topic

Legal Certainty: What are Investors asking for?

March 2021

A few weeks before the new magistrates of the Constitutional Court take office in Guatemala, the business sector is asking that the new members of the highest court advocate for a real rule of law and provide legal certainty to investments.

In recent years, Guatemala's Constitutional Court (CC) has gained prominence in the country's economic sphere, as its rulings have affected different investments that were already operating locally.

Panama: Productive Sector Demands Judicial Independence

October 2016

The union of private companies is promoting a reform that allows strengthening of the administration of justice and ensures the independence of judges and prosecutors.

From a statement issued by the Chamber of Commerce, Industries and Agriculture (CCIAP):

Judicialization of Economic Development

September 2015

The ability of the executive and legislative powers to effectively lead their country's economy is seriously diminished by the excessive actions of the judicial branch, especially the Constitutional Courts.


It is happening in Central America but it is a growing problem throughout Latin America.

Without Legal Certainty There is No Investment

June 2015

If Central America does not strengthen the institutions that ensure a stable legal framework and full respect for contracts, foreign investment will not come and national investment will go to other countries, no matter how many incentives and tax exemptions are offered.