A Ruling Against Democracy and Development in Costa Rica

In contrast to international doctrine on access to public information, a ruling by the Costa Rican Supreme Court has accepted as valid a crude duplicitous technique used to block data management required to a public institution.

Tuesday, August 9, 2016

EDITORIAL

The Constitutional Chamber of Costa Rica has rejected an appeal presented by journalists working for the weekly newspaper El Financiero, thereby validating the use of passwords to prevent computer analysis of a database containing information on wages paid at the State Bank of Costa Rica. See Constitutional Court limits access to free public database (In Spanish).

In the justification for the ruling by the Constitutional Chamber  the following is evident: 1.Horrors over ignorance of technology, 2. Separation from international principles on the right of access to information, 3. Breach of its obligation as a superior court to prevent the use of chicanery to hinder the exercise of the rights of citizens, and 4. An unpardonable ruling in its capacity as principal factor of adaptation of judicial acts to the evolution of life in society.


See: Failure of the Constitutional Chamber
See: Constitutional Court limits access to free public database
See: Principles on the Right of Access to Information  
See: Access to public information, without being able to analyze it, is not real access


(all in Spanish)

¿Busca soluciones de inteligencia comercial para su empresa?



More on this topic

Shameless Justice

October 2018

The representatives of the Supreme Court of Justice of Costa Rica are more concerned with defending their unacceptable privileges than with performing impartially and morally the work for which they were appointed.

EDITORIAL

Arguing that the Tax Reform approved in the first debate in the Congress imposes spending containment measures on the salaries of the Judiciary, the judges of the Supreme Court of Justice announced that they will oppose the reform if the points that affect the operation of the institutions of the Judiciary, in their opinion, are not abolished from it.

Privileges increase prices of gasoline

October 2017

A savings fund, housing loans, expenses for recreation and bonuses, scholarships for children, and restaurant services for employees of the state and the monopolist hydrocarbons distributor of Costa Rica, are financed through the prices paid by consumers, even by the poorest.

OPINION

Public Information Access Law in Effect

September 2011

The Salvadoran President has approved and ordered the publishing of the regulations of the Law on Access to Public Information, which will come into force on 10 September.

A statement by the President of El Salvador reads:

The President, Mauricio Funes, has approved and ordered the publishing of the regulations of the Law on Access to Public Information, which will appear in the Official Gazette on September 2 and will become effective on the 10th of this month.

Fundamental Right to Internet Access Declared

September 2010

Costa Rica's Constitutional Court has ruled that access to the Internet is a fundamental right for all citizens.

The court's declaration means the Costa Rican government must ensure that the whole population can access these new technologies.

Magistrates argued that, "nowadays, public availability of new technology is crucial to enabling people to exercise basic human rights such as democratic participation, education and freedom of speech," reports Nacion.com.

ok